How
to Read a Short Story Critically
(Return
to the Week 1 Schedule)
(Go
to a Sample Short-Story Study)
Reading imaginative
literature in order to learn involves an orderly process. Follow
these steps to get the most from your learning experience of a short story.
Analyze
the Essential Elements of the Story
Analyze
the Structure of the Story
Analyze
Rhetorical Elements
Analyze
the Meaning of the Story (Interpretation)
Analyze the Essential
Elements of the Story
1) Read the text
carefully, noting each character.
You should be able
to identify each character and the essential qualities of each.
2) Identify the
major character(s)--those who seem to control the action or from whose
perspective the story is told.
Distinguish between
major and minor characters. You will know more about major characters
(your list of attributes or characteristics and simple data will be greater
for the major characters). Often, you will be able to identify a
"protagonist" (whose affairs tend to move the story along) and an "antagonist"
(whose affairs or interests seem to contradict the acts and the interests
of the "protagonist"). Minor characters will be less fully developed
and act in concert or motivated by the major characters.
3) Reconstruct
the narrative line--"what happens."
Be able to reconstruct
the "story line," the chain of events that run sequentially from the first
to the last (even though they may not be introduced sequentially).
4) Identify elements
of the plot--"factors which influence the action."
The late British
novelist E. M. Forester in Understanding Fiction suggested a useful distinction
between "narrative line" and "plot." If you want to know the "narrative
live," says Forester, ask "what happens." If you want to know the
plot, ask "why do things happen." For Forester, plot is that set
of events, characters, conditions, themes, and other elements both internal
and external to the work that influence the narrative line to go the way
it does.
5) Discuss the
essential conflict.
Common to all fiction
is conflict. That conflict may be a standoff between characters,
a crossing of wills or goals, a battle between character and setting, even
the struggle against ideas.
(Top)
Analyze the Structure
of the Story
1) Identify the
point(s) of view through which the story is told.
Stories are told
by writers from one or more "points of view." To determine the point
of view of a story, ask, "Who is telling the story?" If the story
seems to move from one scene to another, following no single character,
the story is probably "being told" from the "3rd person" point of view,
sometimes referred to as the "omniscient author's point of view."
"Omniscient" means "to know"; in this case, it refers to the ability of
the author to move in time and space from one venue to another, following
first the actions of one character and then another. If one character
speaks throughout the story, relating the action in his or her own voice,
the story is "being told" through the "1st person" point of view.
2) Explain how
the author uses time.
A journalist reporting
a "story" will usually follow a strict sequential progression of action,
but a writer of fiction is not so constrained. Authors may begin,
for example, in "medias res," that is, in "the middle of things," or jump
back and forth in time. When this happens, the chronology of events
is sometimes difficult to reconstruct sequentially, but the author has
chosen to do so for some reason or special effect. If this happens,
ask yourself why the author has chosen to break with a strictly chronological
or sequential progression of events. What does the story gain from
such development of time?
3) Explain how
the author uses setting.
Stories take place
somewhere, but that "somewhere" can range from a specific historical place
and time to the nebulous, shapeless mind of a character.
4) Explain how
the author uses perspectives (angles).
Sometimes confused
with "point of view," the perspective from which a story is told refers
to the relative positions from which the details are revealed. In filmmaking,
perspective would refer to the "camera angle." Is the "picture" remote
from the subject or "up close and personal." Identify the different
perspectives from which the story is revealed, and if the perspectives
shift, ask yourself why the author orchestrates such shifts. What
does the story gain from these changes in perspective?
(Top)
Analyze Rhetorical
Elements
1) Identify the
author's use of irony (dramatic, situational, verbal).
Irony refers to
"the unexpected." "Dramatic irony" is a sense of the unexpected the reader
experiences while watching the characters of a story act and react without
the wisdom or broader knowledge of the reader. "Situational irony"
refers to the unexpected that comes as a shock to both readers and characters
alike. "Verbal irony," sometimes called "double entendre,"
refers to the use of words with double meanings, usually meanings that
have an important consequence or that are meant to reveal special information
or character.
2) Identify recurring
image patterns.
Images are impressions
of one or more of the five senses. We speak of "visual images," "auditory
images," "tactile images," etc. Words that have references to objects
or entities that we experience sensuously (through the senses) project
imaginative images that remind of us previous experiences or perceptions.
"Image patterns" are the recurring sets of related images that authors
introduce in a story, usually for some reason like helping to develop a
character or project a theme.
3) Explain the
author's use of symbols.
While not all images
are symbols, all symbols are images! That is, some images have only
their normal references as their meaning. However, images that "take
on" meanings beyond their normal references are called "symbols."
Authors use symbols to create implied meaning(s) in their stories.
4) Identify special
uses of language like figures of speech, unusual diction and syntax.
Authors will often
use language patterns that go beyond the normal terms or expressions most
users of the same language would employ to "tell the story." An author's
unique use of words (diction) and sentence patterns (syntax) are the two
elements that characterize his or her style. When a writer chooses
to make an unusual comparison (a figure of speech) or adopts unnatural
terms to characterize a description, explanation, or the voice of a character,
it is usually for some purpose. Ask yourself why the author might
be doing so. Be able to support your interpretation or judgment with
specific examples from the text of the story.
(Top)
Analyze the Meaning
of the Story (Interpretation)
1) Identify what
seems to be the theme and how the author announces it.
The theme of a story
is the dominant message or claim that seems to emerge as the tale evolves.
As such, it can be stated as a complete statement, sometimes as a position
or judgment; other times as an interpretation. Sometimes the theme
can be a single element (motif) like rain, for example, and all that rain
can mean as we understand it from our own and others' experiences of it.
In other cases, the theme may be the promulgation of a certain value.
Themes usually are implied, but occasionally they are even announced by
a character. A character that serves throughout a story to seem to
voice positions or attitudes, values or concerns of an author are special
characters called "personas."
Themes can also be
suggested by image patterns, symbols, features of a setting, and by the
attributes and affairs of characters within a story.
2) Explain how
elements above contribute to the theme.
Be able to cite
specific passages from the text of the story to support your interpretation
of an author's theme(s).
3) Identify contextual
elements (allusions, symbols, other devices) that point beyond the story
to the author's experience/life, history, or to other writings. The
more you learn about an author or read from his or her works, the more
comfortable you will be in analyzing implied meanings like interpretations.
What happens in an author's life can have a very strong influence on a
writer's work, although you should be very cautious about insisting that
every element of a short story have some reference to the author's life.
Like the author's personal experiences, historical events, personalities,
and periods can be sources or influences on an author's works. Watch
for allusions to such elements and be alert to how they seem to affect
both the plot and narrative line as well as character development.
(Top)
This
page was last modified on March 18, 2004,
and
is maintained by Dr.
Geoffrey Grimes.

|