| An Exercise in Critical Reading
(Return to the
Unit 1 Table of Contents)
Instructions: Print out and
read the following brief essay. Identify the main idea of each paragraph
and summarize it in a brief noun or verb phrase in the left margin beside
each paragraph. Keep one annotated copy and e-mail me a list of your annotations
for each paragraph. Follow the instructions I have posted in the
syllabus for submitting e-mails and exercises to me.
Some Words About the Writing Process
1)For many of
us the idea of writing is a fearful enterprise. Getting thoughts together
and organizing them into statements or a pattern that someone else can
understand are difficult tasks. Making writing work right seems sometimes
like a tedious and exasperating prospect if not an outright impossibility.
And to complicate the problem, what many of us have been taught in the
past about the writing process hasn't made the job of composition any easier
or less frightening.
2)"First, you
have to write an appropriate, correct thesis sentence," we have been taught.
"Then, you develop a topic outline and, from it, a sentence outline. Next,
you must organize . . . ." Oh, the grief!
3)An examination
of how experienced or professional writers go about composition reveals,
however, something almost all of us as novice writers already suspect:
a successful piece of writing doesn't just fall into place on the page
like a set of organized blocks, each already pre-formed and grooved to
lock into place against others through an orderly process of arrangement.
4)Successful writing,
rather, is the product of a very fluid, highly flexible process. Successful
writing is the product of constant massaging an idea or set of ideas, trying
first this word and then that one, returning over and over again to reshape
a sentence or reorganize a phrase as new ideas emerge, or as the writer
examines the composition from various angles or points of view.
5)In short, we
can say that writing is a recursive activity, an evolving process of creating
and recreating, revising and revising again, of editing and editing still
one more time. Throughout this process, not only the form of the writing
changes, however, but so does the content.
6)The content
of successful expository writing is insight: its explanation and its marketing.
There are two kinds of insights. An insight is sometimes a startling, new
concept that finds its way into an old, familiar pattern of perceptions.
For example, before the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1989, more and
more U.S. citizens traveling to Russia were discovering that Soviet citizens,
like Americans, want their children to grow up in a world of peace, unthreatened
by the promise of mutually-assured destruction as the inevitable consequence
of any nuclear exchange with the United States. Such a discovery conflicted
with earlier preconceptions of many Americans who projected images of the
Soviet people as essentially war-mongering and bent on world tyranny.
7)So an insight
may be a new discovery that, in its effect, can be very disruptive and
disorienting. On the other hand, an insight might well be an old concept
that suddenly presents itself in a surprising, refreshingly new package--like
the transformation of "Coca Cola" into "Classic Coke." Such a new image,
even without all the corporate fanfare and commotion, can be very satisfying
and reassuring to an old customer.
8)From conception
to dissipation, insights lead an organic life. They are constantly changing
as are our enthusiasm for them, sometimes flushed and fevered, at other
times heedless and lethargic. Upon discovery, an insight can carry about
it the electric aura of the visionary, crashing into our consciousness
with all the thunder of a revelation. After hanging out in our heads for
a while, however, insights tend to mellow, first into convictions and,
over time, into opinions. Even as opinions, however, insights become networks
of "truth statements" which, without nurturing, can either harden into
mindsets or dissolve into intellectual debris.
9)Whether as an
exciting, new widget on the faded kitchen counter or as the same tired,
overstuffed body in a flashy, tapered sport jacket, insights are always
the focus of communication between a writer and his or her audience. But
what constitutes insight for one person may be something much less provocative
and interesting for a potential audience. Through the recursive phases
of the writing process, like the form, the con-tent also must change. That
change is nothing short of a transformation.
10)The change that
insight must undergo in any successful communication is the transformation
of private insight into public insight. Or, perhaps we could characterize
the change as a "transference" rather than a "transformation," a transference
of insight from the writer to the audience. Whichever expression we select--"transform"
or "transfer"--an idea of value and importance for us must somehow, in
the writing process, become an idea of value and importance for an audience.
That is what I meant above when I referred to "marketing" the insight.
Somehow, in the writing process, we must "sell" our private insight to
our audience. Our insight must enter the public domain.
11)How does that
happen? How do we get an audience to buy our product? To answer that, we
must begin the writing process. It will mean more to you ultimately to
have experienced the answer than for me to have told you the answer. In
this exercise, then, you will watch yourself work through the four very
distinct phases of writing: creating, drafting, revising, and editing.
12)You will also
witness the process of transformation of your insight into public insight
as you become increasingly more objective about your writing (both the
process and the product) and more attentive to the needs and interests
of your audience. Your writing experiences in this unit will (1) make you
feel more comfortable about your own unique approach to composition and
(2) make you more conscious of your own process of writing.
Geoffrey Grimes
(Return to
the Top)
This page was last modified on September 13, 2011,
and is maintained by Dr. Geoffrey Grimes.
|